A single image summarising this page

Frontier models compared (November 2026)

Scope: five current flagship models, compared on the axes that only matter before you sign: prompt caching, Batch discounts, ZDR, ZOA, training use and data residency. Per-token rates match our pricing table; anything we could not verify is marked not confirmed rather than filled in.

●Last updated: | Official vendor pages fetched 2026-11-14 (Gemini 4 Carbon context window and max output re-checked 2026-11-15). Figures are quoted verbatim; cells we could not source are marked not confirmed.

The five models

Model (official name)VendorPositionDetails
Claude Fable 5.2AnthropicReleased 2026-11-09; successor to Fable 5.1 at 20% lower ratesFable 5.1 deep dive
GPT-6 AstraOpenAIFlagship announced 2026-09-03GPT-6 Astra deep dive
Gemini 4 CarbonGoogleAnnounced 2026-10-28. The pricing page lists input $2.00 / output $10.00 (no free tier)Pricing / Timeline
Kimi K3.1 ProMoonshot AILive 2026-10-23; weights published 2026-11-04Kimi K3.1 Pro deep dive
Meta Muse WonderMetaLaunched 2026-10-12; API exposes muse-wonder-1.0 onlyTimeline

The larger Muse Wonder Full is available only through Muse Code subscriptions, not the public API, so it is outside this comparison.

Three things to take away

  • Cache read discounts span 4x across the five models. The deepest is Claude Fable 5.2 at 0.025x (97.5% off); Muse Wonder sits in the middle at 0.05x (95% off); the shallowest is 0.1x (90% off) on GPT-6 Astra and Kimi K3.1 Pro. For a workload that resends the same prefix, the multiplier can matter more than the headline input rate.
  • Discount rate and absolute price are different questions. The most expensive cached read here is GPT-6 Astra at $1.00; Fable 5.2, Kimi K3.1 Pro and Muse Wonder all sit at $0.20.
  • Choosing ZDR costs you features. Meta states that with ZDR enabled, server-side conversation state, background requests, file uploads, web search and Contributor mode are unavailable. Retention settings and feature settings are the same switch.

1. Rates (USD per 1M tokens, standard tier)

ModelInputOutputCache readWrite 5 minWrite 1 hourNotes
Claude Fable 5.2$8.00$40.00$0.20
0.025x
$10.00
1.25x
$16.00
2x
Fast mode $16 / $80
GPT-6 Astra$10.00$50.00$1.00
0.1x
Not confirmedNot confirmedLong tier $20 / $2 / $75. Fast mode 2x
Gemini 4 Carbon$2.00
$4.00 from 1 Dec
$10.00
$20.00 from 1 Dec
$0.10
$0.20 from 1 Dec
Not listedNot listedImplicit caching only (no explicit caching)
Kimi K3.1 Pro$2.00$10.00$0.20
0.1x
$2.00$4.00Highspeed tier is 2x
Meta Muse Wonder$4.00$20.00$0.20
95% off
Not confirmedNot confirmedNo long-context premium

Fable 5.2 cache rates were read off the Claude pricing page with the column headers intact (fetched 2026-11-14): 5m writes $10, 1h writes $16, hits and refreshes $0.20. Our earlier "not confirmed" came from a summary table showing "Prompt caching $40", which looked like a 5x marker; the breakdown is now resolved.

2. Cache mechanics (minimum length, retention, mode)

ModelModeMinimum cacheableRetention (TTL)What it means
Claude Fable 5.2Explicit (cache_control)Not confirmedChoose 5 minutes or 1 hour at write timeThe only one of the five where you pick the TTL
GPT-6 AstraAutomatic + explicit1,024
(stated for the GPT-6.1 line; Astra-specific value not confirmed)
30 min default; 12 h option in the Responses API
(GPT-6.1 line)
Works on short prefixes, but the read rate is the highest here
Gemini 4 CarbonImplicit onlyNot listedNot listedNo explicit caching means you cannot set the boundary yourself
Kimi K3.1 ProAutomatic by defaultNot confirmed5 min default; each hit refreshes the TTLNo configuration needed; weak for long-lived reuse
Meta Muse WonderAutomaticNot confirmedNot confirmedUnder ZDR, server-side state is unavailable entirely

For explicit vs implicit caching, see the glossary entry; per-model rates are in Prompt caching rates compared.

3. Batch discounts and combining with cache

ModelBatch discountBatch rate (calculated)Combine with cache?
Claude Fable 5.250% off$4.00 / $20.00Yes — "Batch API and prompt caching discounts can be combined."
GPT-6 Astra50% off$5.00 / $25.00Not confirmed
Gemini 4 CarbonNot supported—— ("Batch API isn't supported")
Kimi K3.1 Pro60% of standard$1.20 / $6.00Not confirmed
Meta Muse WonderNot confirmed——

Turnaround, retention windows and limits are in Batch API discounts compared. Batch rates here are calculated (standard rate x discount), not figures each vendor published separately.

4. Data controls (ZDR, ZOA, training, residency)

ModelZDRZOA (operator access)Training (API default)Data location
Claude Fable 5.2On request
Fable 5.1 and earlier are Covered Models requiring 30-day retention and are excluded from ZDR; whether 5.2 is on that list is not confirmed
Controlled access path
Customer-managed keys not confirmed
Commercial terms: no training on Customer ContentNo region choice on the first-party API (not even EU)
GPT-6 AstraApproval required
Zero Data Retention or Modified Abuse Monitoring customers only
Safety review runtime designed to disable human access; EKMNot used for training by default on the APIStorage selectable; processing is not (Japan: storage yes, processing no)
Gemini 4 CarbonAvailable on Google Cloud
customer-side configuration required
Access Approval / Access Transparency / KAJPaid tier: not used. Free tier (Unpaid Services) is used for improvement with human reviewGoogle Cloud supports region selection; AI Studio location not confirmed
Kimi K3.1 ProNot confirmedNot confirmedNot confirmedNot confirmed
Meta Muse WonderApproval required
qualified Meta Model API accounts; ZDR disables stateful requests, background requests, file uploads and web search
Not confirmedNot confirmed
Contributor mode is unavailable under ZDR per the official help centre
Not confirmed

ZDR, ZOA, training and residency are separate documents. Background: ZDR / ZOA / training use / data residency. Satisfying one does not satisfy another.

5. Context window and output ceiling

ModelContext windowMax outputLong-context billing
Claude Fable 5.2Not confirmed
Fable 5.1 is 1M
Not confirmed
5.1 is 128K
No tiered pricing (per 5.1)
GPT-6 Astra1.05M128KLong tier $20 / $2 / $75
Gemini 4 Carbon1M tokens64K / 1M tokensNo long-context tiering listed on the pricing page (source: ai.google.dev/gemini-api/docs/models, retrieved 2026-11-15)
Kimi K3.1 Pro1,048,576Not confirmedNone listed
Meta Muse Wonder1MNot confirmedNo long-context premium

Cells we could not confirm

ItemModelWhy it is missing
Minimum cacheable lengthFable 5.2 / Kimi K3.1 Pro / Muse WonderNo minimum token count in the pricing pages we fetched, and none in Anthropic's caching docs either
Cache write rateGPT-6 Astra / Muse WonderThe official cache rate table has no row for these models
ZDR, ZOA, training, residencyKimi K3.1 ProNo verbatim quote obtainable from the official data-handling pages; third-party summaries exist but are not primary sources
ZOA and residencyMeta Muse WonderThe official help centre covers ZDR only
Context window and max outputClaude Fable 5.2 / GPT-6 AstraNot on the pricing pages; model docs not yet retrieved verbatim
Batch discountMeta Muse WonderNo Batch-equivalent statement found on Meta's pricing page
Availability stage (GA / preview)Gemini 4 CarbonGenerally available (GA) on 2026-11-10. The pricing page itself carries no stage label, so the stage is recorded from the operator's confirmation (okamo); the rates come only from the paid-tier figures on that page

"Not confirmed" does not mean "not available". We fill cells only from primary sources, and update them as we verify each one.

Sources (all fetched 2026-11-14)

  • Anthropic — Pricing (Fable 5.2 $8 in / $40 out, 5m writes $10, 1h writes $16, hits $0.20, Batch 50% off)
  • OpenAI — pricing page (GPT-6 Astra $10 / $50, cached input $1.00) and model page (1.05M context, 128K output)
  • Google — Gemini Developer API pricing (Carbon $2.00/$10.00 rising to $4.00/$20.00 on 1 Dec; cache $0.10 to $0.20; implicit only) and the Gemini 4 Hydrogen announcement (Carbon: "Batch API isn't supported")
  • Moonshot AI — platform.kimi.ai pricing page (K3.1 Pro $2.00 / $10.00, cache read $0.20, writes $2.00 for 5m and $4.00 for 1h, Batch at 60% of standard)
  • Meta — Model API: Zero Data Retention ("ZDR is available for qualified Meta Model API accounts" plus the list of unavailable features) and the pricing page ($4.00 / $20.00, cached input $0.20, 1M context)

Related pages